“Silos, Politics, and Turf Wars” by Patrick Lencioni
Source: Excerpts from “Silos_Politics_and_Turf_Wars_-_Patrick_M_Lencioni.pdf”
Date: October 26, 2023
Overview:
This book addresses the pervasive problem of silos (departmental politics and territoriality) in organizations, arguing that they “waste resources, kill productivity, and jeopardize the achievement of goals.” Lencioni proposes a simple, powerful tool for addressing the root causes of silos, rather than focusing on superficial behavioral solutions. The book uses a fable format to illustrate the problem and its solution, following the journey of Jude Cousins, a consultant, as he grapples with these issues.
Key Themes and Ideas:
- The Problem of Silos:
- Silos are a persistent and frustrating issue in organizations. As Lencioni states in the introduction, “When I told some of my clients that I was planning to write a book about silos, they seemed to have a universally visceral reaction: ‘Pleeease write that book. The silos in this company are driving me crazy!'”
- Traditional approaches (training programs, memos, posters) that aim to inspire people to “work better together” often fail because they don’t address the underlying contextual issues.
- Silos lead to wasted resources, decreased productivity, and hinder the achievement of organizational goals.
- Jude’s Journey: From Corporate Employee to Consultant:
- Jude Cousins, initially a marketing executive at Hatch Technology, becomes disillusioned with corporate life after a merger intensifies internal politics. He observes that “infighting had risen to a new level entirely. Attention had shifted drastically inward, away from issues like customers and competitors and toward battles over budgets, titles, and responsibility for mistakes.”
- He leaves to become a consultant, initially struggling to define his service offering.
- Through client interactions and observations (particularly at JMJ Fitness and Children’s Hospital), Jude discovers the widespread pain caused by silos.
- He realizes that his clients consistently complain about “departmental politics, or infighting, or lack of divisional cooperation.”
- The “Fire Drill” Concept and Shared Vulnerability:
- Jude learns from Brian Bailey at JMJ Fitness that a past crisis (a “Fire Drill”) paradoxically eliminated their silo problem. A near-disaster scenario had forced employees to unite and collaborate. As Brian said, “Sometimes I think that was the best thing that ever happened to this company.”
- Jude observes that during the crisis at JMJ Fitness, “the only way to salvage morale was to get everyone involved, even a little pissed off, about what had happened to us. They came up with ideas that none of us up here would have had the courage for.”
- From this, he infers that a shared sense of vulnerability or common cause can break down departmental barriers. He concludes, “I think a company should find a way to rally people around a common cause before a crisis hits.”
- Lencioni’s Theory: A Framework for Breaking Down Silos:
- The core of Lencioni’s approach involves rallying executives and employees around a Thematic Goal.
- Thematic Goal: A qualitative, overarching objective shared across the entire team. Examples include:
- Completing the merger of organizations
- Establish an infrastructure for continued growth.
- To regain the momentum that we once had…To go on the offensive.”
- Defining Objectives: Qualitative components that clarify the Thematic Goal. They are also time-bound. Example objectives related to the “Establish an infrastructure for continued growth” include:
- Installing a more scalable and comprehensive accounting system.
- Upgrading the customer tracking system.
- Standard Operating Objectives: Measurable goals related to daily business (e.g., revenue, cash flow, customer retention).
- This framework provides a context for staff meetings and decision-making, helping to prioritize initiatives based on their impact on shared goals rather than departmental agendas.
- “Because now if anyone argues for something that’s good for their department or functional area but doesn’t have a meaningful impact on any of these things,” (the board containing the thematic goal, defining objectives, and standard operating objectives) “then we’ll all be able to explain why it shouldn’t be a priority.”
- Implementation and Results:
- Jude implements this approach at Children’s Hospital, the Madison Hotel, and, ultimately, at his former employer, Batch Technology.
- Batch Technology experiences significant success, using the thematic goal framework to integrate new acquisitions and refocus on collective interests.
- Cousins Consulting thrives, with Jude ultimately addressing the issue even within his own growing firm, recognizing the potential for silos to emerge even in a consulting company focused on eliminating them.
Key Quote:
“To tear down silos, leaders must go beyond behaviors and address the contextual issues at the heart of departmental separation and politics.”
Implications:
This book offers a practical framework for leaders seeking to address silos in their organizations. By focusing on a shared, qualitative “thematic goal” and aligning objectives accordingly, organizations can foster collaboration, improve productivity, and achieve their goals. The framework is meant to create a shared purpose and focus, aligning all team members and allowing them to see how they can contribute to the success of the organization.
RYT Podcast is a passion product of Tyler Smith, an EOS® Implementer (more at IssueSolving.com). All Podcasts are derivative works created by AI from publicly available sources. Copyright 2025 All Rights Reserved.
